It took 484 endless days and nights for Keith Shmuel Siegel to be released from Hamas captivity as part of a ceasefire agreement. It is a return to life – with the awareness that the horror continues for the remaining hostages.
By Delly Hezel
As I write this report, Avishai Argentaro, a survivor of the Hamas massacre of October 7, 2023, from Kfar Aza, is in my kitchen cooking. The aroma is wonderful, and the food tastes even better. I'm allowed to sample the results of his culinary skills again and again – simply delicious!
Avishai is a cook, or more precisely, a chef. His catering company is known in Israel as "Chef 232," named after Route 232, which leads to his home in Kfar Aza, a kibbutz near the Gaza Strip. On October 7, 2023, Route 232 gained tragic notoriety—it was the road where Hamas terrorists committed some of their most horrific acts. The road that became a death trap for so many—there was no escape.
Keith Shmuel Siegel also uses this street as his home route. He, too, lives in Kfar Aza. His son Shay and the cook Avishay are friends. They were friends even before they started kindergarten, as they grew up in the same neighborhood. Avishay and Shay were also among the first guests I hosted in 2012 as part of the Christians Standing with Israel terror victim support program. It was through them that I came into contact with Keith

Keith's story
When Hamas attacked Kibbutz Kfar Aza on October 7, 2023, Keith was wounded: he suffered a gunshot wound and broken ribs when the terrorists forcibly dragged him through the window of the shelter in his house. He initially refused to reveal the code to his car's immobilizer, but his wife, Aviva, begged him to comply. She preferred to be abducted alive rather than die on the spot. And so, Keith and Aviva were taken to the Gaza Strip in their own car.
They were convinced that their son Shay had not survived the massacre. Contact with him had been lost, but through the kibbutz's WhatsApp group, they knew what had happened. Aviva and Keith, along with other hostages, were held captive in Hamas tunnels beneath the Gaza Strip. They were subjected to daily violence and the terrorists' arbitrary cruelty. Despite all this, Keith managed to remain grateful. Every day, he and the other hostages searched for something to be thankful for. It was a desperate attempt to cling to the light in the darkest darkness. Sometimes they were thankful for the half-baked pita they shared.
For Aviva, after 51 days, came what was probably the hardest moment of her ordeal: she was to be released, but without Keith. She wanted to stay with him. She couldn't withstand the terrorists' threats, and so they said goodbye to each other in tears. Aviva felt torn apart.
Back to freedom
On February 1, 2025, after 484 days in captivity and 433 days after Aviva's release, Keith's moment of freedom finally arrived. A quiet, friendly family man, he had learned Arabic over thirty years earlier to communicate with the Palestinians working on his kibbutz. His daughter Elan said of him: "He is a person who did only good things his whole life, who believed in goodness and loved everyone. He was denied the chance to say goodbye to the person who raised him and loved him his entire life." She was referring to his mother: The 97-year-old passed away in December 2024. She did not live to see her son's return.
Freed Keith Siegel thanks Donald Trump for his release. The American president is the reason he can be reunited with his wife Aviva, his four children, and five grandchildren. Keith describes himself as a 65-year-old Israeli with American citizenship who loves country music and pancakes on Shabbat mornings. Since February 1, 2025, he has also been a freed hostage. A survivor.
Regarding his captivity, Keith says: “For 484 days, I was held captive under unimaginable conditions. Every day felt like my last. Terrorists kicked me, spat on me, and refused to give me water. I was kept in the dark and felt like I couldn't breathe. They tortured me and starved me.” Addressing Trump, he adds: “I trust in your leadership and strength, Mr. President. The helpless hostages in the cold, dark tunnels of Gaza trust you too. Please bring them home.”
Keith is finally home again. And Avishai baked his beloved pancakes for him for Shabbat morning.
This article first appeared in our newspaper "Israelaktuell," issue 140. You can order the newspaper here . We would also be happy to send you several copies for distribution.